-

* Please note all CISAC events are scheduled using the Pacific Time Zone.

 

Register in advance for this webinar: https://stanford.zoom.us/webinar/register/8416226562432/WN_WLYcdRa6T5Cs1MMdmM0Mug

 

About the Event: Is there a place for illegal or nonconsensual evidence in security studies research, such as leaked classified documents? What is at stake, and who bears the responsibility, for determining source legitimacy? Although massive unauthorized disclosures by WikiLeaks and its kindred may excite qualitative scholars with policy revelations, and quantitative researchers with big-data suitability, they are fraught with methodological and ethical dilemmas that the discipline has yet to resolve. I argue that the hazards from this research—from national security harms, to eroding human-subjects protections, to scholarly complicity with rogue actors—generally outweigh the benefits, and that exceptions and justifications need to be articulated much more explicitly and forcefully than is customary in existing work. This paper demonstrates that the use of apparently leaked documents has proliferated over the past decade, and appeared in every leading journal, without being explicitly disclosed and defended in research design and citation practices. The paper critiques incomplete and inconsistent guidance from leading political science and international relations journals and associations; considers how other disciplines from journalism to statistics to paleontology address the origins of their sources; and elaborates a set of normative and evidentiary criteria for researchers and readers to assess documentary source legitimacy and utility. Fundamentally, it contends that the scholarly community (researchers, peer reviewers, editors, thesis advisors, professional associations, and institutions) needs to practice deeper reflection on sources’ provenance, greater humility about whether to access leaked materials and what inferences to draw from them, and more transparency in citation and research strategies.

View Written Draft Paper

 

About the Speaker: Christopher Darnton is a CISAC affiliate and an associate professor of national security affairs at the Naval Postgraduate School. He previously taught at Reed College and the Catholic University of America, and holds a Ph.D. in Politics from Princeton University. He is the author of Rivalry and Alliance Politics in Cold War Latin America (Johns Hopkins, 2014) and of journal articles on US foreign policy, Latin American security, and qualitative research methods. His International Security article, “Archives and Inference: Documentary Evidence in Case Study Research and the Debate over U.S. Entry into World War II,” won the 2019 APSA International History and Politics Section Outstanding Article Award. He is writing a book on the history of US security cooperation in Latin America, based on declassified military documents.

Virtual Seminar

Christopher Darnton Associate Professor of National Security Affairs Naval Postgraduate School
Seminars
All Publications button
1
Publication Type
Journal Articles
Publication Date
Subtitle

Empirical research so far largely suggests that population policies around the world do not explain a majority of the global fertility decline. Notably, even China’s total fertility rate declined little after implementation of the one-child policy in 1979 and 1980, but fertility then fell sharply by more than one-third during the early 1990s. Here we show that strengthening bureaucratic incentives under China’s one vote veto policy, which strictly prohibited career advancement for adherence failure, was instrumental in more effective implementation of the one-child policy, and in its delayed impact on fertility. Using provincial variation in implementation timing, we find that the one vote veto explains nearly half of China’s total fertility rate decline during the 1990s, driving fertility below the replacement rate. Increases in use of intrauterine devices (the most prevalent form of modern contraception in China) that were recommended by local officials were particularly salient. Overall, our findings suggest that population policy, when more strictly enforced due to stronger bureaucratic incentives, made a greater contribution to low fertility in China than suggested by past research.

Journal Publisher
Nature
Authors
Lingsheng Meng
Grant Miller
Hongbin Li
Authors
Melissa Morgan
News Type
Commentary
Date
Paragraphs

There’s no shortage of threats facing the globe, from challenges to democracy to emerging capabilities like artificial intelligence and biotechnology, to ongoing conflicts between Russia and Ukraine, the United States and Iran, and the potential for conflict between China and Taiwan.

At Stanford's 2026 Reunion Homecoming weekend, Colin Kahl led a conversation with a panel of scholars from the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies on some of the major challenges currently facing the globe.

Drew Endy highlighted the need to secure the biotechnology frontier, as AI makes it ever more possible for bad actors to bring bioweapons to life. Didi Kuo discussed where democracy is doing well, and what can be done to push back against authoritarianism. Abbas Milani provided personal and scholarly insights into the conflict in Iran and the country's democratic potential. Steven Pifer debunked the idea that Russia is making meaningful progress in its war of aggression against Ukraine, and outlines how the United States can be more effective as a negotiator between the two sides. And Oriana Skylar Mastro shared what people are getting wrong about competition with China, and where more nuance is needed in understanding the U.S.-China relationship. 

While each of these challenges is significant, they are not unsolvable.

“These are not inevitabilities. These are choices," reminds Colin Kahl. "We can choose to engineer a world of abundance and opportunity, or we can create a lot of dangerous things that make life worse. We can choose to defend freedom in the United States and around the world, or we can choose not to. We can choose to wield American power with wisdom and with a degree of restraint, or unwisely with hubris, like an international wrecking ball. We can keep the problems solvable.”

To learn more from these scholars, check out their books:


Watch the full panel discussion in the video above. A podcast version is available in the player below. If you like what you hear, be sure to follow, like and subscribe to World Class on your favorite podcast platform.

TRANSCRIPT:


Kahl: You're listening to World Class from the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies at Stanford University. I'm your host, Colin Kahl, the director of FSI.

Today I'm bringing you a discussion I had with an amazing group of FSI scholars during Stanford's 2026 Reunion Homecoming weekend. We surveyed many trends and threats facing the world today, including the development of bioweapons, challenges to democracy around the world, the war between Russia and Ukraine, Chinese ambitions against Taiwan, and the U.S.-Iran conflict.

These are complicated issues and the challenges to addressing them are real, but so are the opportunities for resolving them. We're going to hear from Drew Endy, a world-recognized expert on bioengineering and biosecurity; Didi Kuo, who specializes in comparative politics, democracy, and the role of political parties; Abbas Milani, a leading voice in Iranian studies and one of the most authoritative contemporary scholars on what's happening to Iranian society; Steven Pifer, a former U.S. ambassador to Ukraine and expert on European defense; and finally, Oriana Skylar Mastro, a scholar of the Chinese military and Indo-Pacific security.

It was a great conversation, and I hope you find it as informative as I did. Here's the panel.

[BEGIN EVENT RECORDING]

Kahl: All right, so I'm going start and we're going to go down the line, and then I'll ask another round and we'll go down the line.

So, Drew, starting with you: what's one thing that the world should understand — maybe something they currently don't understand, or maybe they think they understand, but they're getting wrong — about biosecurity, biotechnology, and how it's poised to change everything.

Endy: So let's start with what we know. Somebody died in Russia of a plague. We have soldiers coming back from the front lines in Ukraine with resistant bacteria. We have Ebola in DRC; it's going to be the worst we've seen in a while, that outbreak. And I had COVID two weeks ago for the fourth or fifth time, I've lost track. It's so last decade, but it's going to kill 50,000 Americans this year, plus or minus. You know that, right? Everybody knows that.

I'm as you mentioned from bioengineering, bioengineering is the youngest engineering department at Stanford. We're twenty some years old. The second youngest is Computer Science. When I moved here to Stanford, research was being done—you know, Karl Deisseroth, who got the Nobel Prize recently—put one gene from a bacteria into neurons to use light to control neurons. That was work he did twenty years ago in bioengineering.

What do you think we've been doing? We've been getting better at bioengineering. One thing that's changing is how we manufacture. If you can encode a way of manufacturing something in the DNA, you can grow what you want where you can operate the biology.

When you leave this room, take a look at a leaf on a tree and think about it from an engineer's perspective. It's a solar panel that makes itself and recycles itself. It's pulling 120 terawatts of net energy on the surface of the earth. We have a capability in front of us to change how we make most of the things we need. We had an internet over the last fifty years that got built for communication resilience. We're going to have a “bio net”: download and grow — download DNA code, grow what you want, you can get it encoded where you are, for manufacturing resilience.

I was flying back from Washington on Wednesday. I was on seat 20A in United, window seat exit row, and I decided to design a genome. And so I opened up Claude on my laptop and I started feeding it PDF files of different genetic sequences and we started dancing. And before I landed at SFO and before my battery went to zero, I had designed a synthetic genome for a bacteria. 

What people are sleeping on a little bit is we're making biology engineerable for good reasons. I don't wake up in the morning thinking about how am I gonna make a WMD? But it's a domain that's becoming engineerable and it's a domain we haven't secured yet. And so it's like, hmm.

In so many different dimensions, we are on this journey of profound, profound change.

Kahl: Speaking of things that are radioactive, Didi, our politics. What's one thing that the folks in this room should understand that maybe they aren't currently tracking?

Kuo: So I actually think Americans and Stanford alum really do understand what's going on. Well over 70 to 80% of Americans are concerned about the state of democracy, both at home and abroad. They're concerned about levels of corruption, about attacks on freedom of speech, on attacks on election integrity, sometimes for very different reasons. But I guess I would yes and that sentiment.

First, this is not an American story. This is happening globally. We are almost entering our twentieth year of what our colleague Larry Diamond calls the global democratic recession, which means a lot of the democratization and optimism of the 1990s has either become stagnant or even been undone.

And that is a problem because even in places that were once thought immune from problems of democracy, we see leaders pursuing the same strategies: going after their opponents, weaponizing the state, repressing civil society. So you know that people are unhappy with their governments, which is often why they elect radical leaders in the first place.

But the second thing that I would say — in addition to understanding that this is global and that that's something we need to kind of drill down and investigate — is that there are actually signs of hope from around the world.

We know that democratic backsliding can be reversed. And we've seen some of those strategies be very successful abroad. And I think we've seen signs of them start to be successful here.

First, we know that massive collective action, civil resistance, and nonviolent protest can really work to bring attention to the things that Americans care about and to stop the worst kinds of violence and repression.

The second thing is institutional defenses, when people who are suddenly finding their jobs politicized or trying to be eradicated or undone, and they try to safeguard their jobs and their roles in various positions, whether they're bureaucrats or judges, tax officers, people who work at universities, law firms, et cetera. That also has a huge effect on stopping democratic erosion. 

But the number one thing is to vote in elections. The number one antidote to democratic backsliding is baked into our very system, and that is democracy itself.

We know that leaders often try to attack elections, but that you can actually create these pro-democracy coalitions across people with very different ideological and policy values and alignments and say, we're actually going to protect this fundamental process of democracy so that we can live to fight another day in the future and try to get all of our policy issues sorted out then.

And I think that we've seen the signs of that here in Minnesota earlier this year, and certainly a lot of mobilization and excitement about the midterm elections and about elections happening in Israel and Brazil and in other places around the world, France, are going to have democracy on the line. But people, when they are threatened, will work to protect democracy.

Kahl: All right. Abbas. Few people, seriously, in the world understand the dynamics inside Iran and Iran's impact on the region in the world better than you. What is one thing we could better understand about the conflict in the Middle East or Iran more generally?

Milani: One thing you can understand is that according to some in the Iranian regime, World War Three has already started. It is between Iran and Israel and the United States, and that Iran is winning. That's their version of the reality.

What I think the world doesn't get about Iran is that it is indeed a very paradoxical society. She talked about democratic backsliding. Iran has been a democratically forward sliding society in the last twenty five years.

I would seriously say, and I've written about this several places, that Iran at the societal level is right now arguably the most democratic society in the Muslim Middle East. And every day people are more and more fighting for democracy, from women to minorities to men who are siding with women. Iran has had — in spite of having the most misogynist set of laws on the books — I think arguably has the most active, progressive, prudent women's movement. in the last thirty years.

The Life Women Liberty movement is remarkable. So I think only comparable to the African American movement for civil rights in sixties and seventies in terms of its success.

So you have a paradoxical society, a profoundly despotic society, every day becoming more organized in its despotism. Today we have virtually a military dictatorship in Iran, but at the societal level it is a very dynamic society that wants democracy, women who wants equality.

There are two Irans: the Iran of the Iranian people and the Iran of this regime. And the world policy, U.S. policy doesn't seem to get this very important schism that is at the heart of the Iranian society, the paradox that exists.

Kahl: Steve, unfortunately there's also the largest conflict in Europe since the Second World War. There's been a lot of news on Ukraine. There is always every week, but it seems like the last week has been pretty newsworthy. What should we be understanding more about the current war?

Pifer: Well, I would say Russia is not winning the war on the battlefield in Ukraine, and the campaign now is shifting to target Ukrainian cities and Ukrainian civilians. Ukraine's pretty much stabilized the battlefront.

As they developed over the last two years, drones that can strike more deeply into Russia, they focused on Russian oil refineries. And they've probably . . . I think the IAES estimate was about thirty percent of Russian refining capability now has been taken offline. Now the Russians rebuild it, the Ukrainians attack it again. But that's a legitimate military target.

I mean, those fuels go to power the drones, they go to power the planes, they go to power the Russian tanks. It hasn't yet pushed the Russians to the point where the Russians have begun to negotiate in any more serious way, but it was increasing economic pressure on Russia.

Over the last nine and a half months since January 1st, Russia's gained a net total of about a hundred square kilometers of Ukrainian territory. For perspective, that's less than the size of the city of San Francisco. Ukraine is the size of Texas.

And to do that, the Russians are paying an enormous cost. Thirty to forty thousand Russian soldiers are either killed or severely wounded every single month. And given that failure on the battlefield, what you see is that the Russians are now shifting the campaign to Ukrainian cities. And the hope is that they can weaponize winter, winter's cold against the Ukrainians and break their will. So they target electric power plants, they target large steam facilities that heat the major cities, they target water facilities.

And they do a lot that's simply harassment. So I have on my phone here when I was in Kyiv about two years ago, I downloaded an air raid app. In the last several weeks for Kyiv, they're getting six to ten air raids every single day. And when that goes off at four o'clock in the morning, somebody has to say, do I drag my family down to the bomb shelter for the third time tonight, or do I tell them to sleep and we play the odds?

Now it's going to be a difficult winner for Ukraine. But I think Ukrainians have shown they're resilient. I think the Russian effort's going to fail, and this war unfortunately is going to continue well into 2027.

And the unfortunate thing here is that President Trump has significant leverage that he could use to push the Russians to negotiate a settlement to this war. And he has chosen not to use it. In fact, we've seen even last night by waiving new sanctions on Russia, he's actually gone over to the Russian side. And I think that's going to be a very dark stain on Americans' global reputation.

Kahl: There's conflict of instability in the Middle East, horrible events in Europe. For years, folks in Washington have wanted to pivot to Asia or the Indo-Pacific to focus on the emerging challenges there.

Oriana, what could we better understand about the storm clouds that might be gathering (or not) in the Indo-Pacific, especially across the Taiwan Strait?

Mastro: So I'm gonna cheat a little bit and say everything. I do a lot of research and writing about China, Taiwan, about the Indo-Pacific security, and China is such a complex place. And we have to have nuanced understandings about what is happening there, what is happening across the Taiwan Strait. And in most of the public debate, you either get an extremely dovish view or an extremely hawkish view, and the reality is somewhere in the middle.

For example, it is true that the United States is now distracted with wars in Ukraine and Iran and elsewhere. We have spent 147% of China's full military budget on those conflicts already. So it's very hard to compete with China conventionally in the military sphere when we are being less disciplined about how we're spending our time and effort.

At the same token, it is not the case that because we are distracted today, China has a higher likelihood of taking Taiwan by force. What convinces the Chinese whether to do that or not is not so much whether the United States is distracted in another part of the world, but on their own military competency.

Xi Jinping just did a huge purge of the most senior military leaders there that are currently either missing or at house arrest. So it's not the case that they're waiting for a moment, a window of opportunity.

It's the same thing when you look at China and Russia and what that means for Taiwan. Should we be concerned about China-Russia? Of course we should, but not because these two countries are going to fight a war together. That kind of misses the mark.

Instead, they help each other in peacetime build up their militaries in ways that makes it really hard for us to deter China from using force and if there's a conflict to compel China to stop fighting. I think we see that already in Ukraine; a little bit of Chinese support can go a really long way.

And the last example I will give about this nuanced balance is about the economy. It is true that the Chinese economy is not doing well. But there's no evidence to suggest that that convinces the Communist Party that they have to do some sort of wag-the-dog maneuver to use force in a Taiwan contingency to distract the public. If anything, their strategic culture goes the opposite way; when they have problems at home, they focus inward.

So all of this is to say I'm very vocal about my concerns about the likelihood of conflict over the Taiwan Strait. I think the Chinese have been very clear that they're preparing, they're building their military, they don't want to wait forever to solve this issue. And it's an issue that cannot be solved without force.

But not for all the reasons that potentially we hear in the news for why we should be concerned.

Kahl: Thank you very much. I think one of the things, the common threads across is the urgency around all of these issues. Dynamics in Washington may change a bit, but the reality is whether one loves President Trump or doesn't particularly like what he's doing, he's the president for the next two years. And a lot of really important decisions that impact the world will happen in that two year period.

So, Drew: if you had five minutes with the president on your issue, what would you try to get the president to do that he's maybe not doing enough of, or get him to stop doing what he's doing too much of?

Endy: A couple of things I'd like him to do, but on on this topic today, I'd say, Mr. President, there's never been a better time to secure biology. We could actually know what airborne viruses are in this room right now. We'd need a little machine with a box about the size of that podium and we'd be running it and doing air sampling. Now's the time to secure biology.

I'd pick on his statement from the UNGA over a year ago, where in the middle of a speech he declared that all nations should stand together to end the scourge of bioweapons. I'll take that.

I'd like the president of China and the President of the United States to duet. If I had the magic teleprompter, they should be saying that together, because that by itself will be insufficient. We need to get a duty to notify in place, a hotline for bio threats. If you have the emergence of a pandemic potential outbreak, we talk to each other. Never again do we have the Wuhan ambiguity. And we probably need that biodefense hotline with Moscow as well.

What does that look like operationally? With nuclear security, we've got the NNSA, the National Nuclear Security Agency Administration. $30 billion dollars a year. That, through the weapons lab, gets our nuclear force ready to go.

I'd argue we should have an NBSA: a National Biosecurity Agency. It would be about $10 billion dollars a year. It's not going to run on the high side. We don't put it in the weapons lab, because that'd be really bad. We do it in the public to the greatest extent possible.

So, Mr. President, there's never been a better time to secure biology. We can do it. It can be an enduring legacy. The returns are amazing. I have some other things I need him to do, but like on this topic, we can secure biology.

Kahl: All right. Didi, five minutes with the president.

Kuo: I doubt I would have any impact, but I would make appeals to two things that seem to matter to him. One is money. Okay. So he really likes to make money off of public office. That's called corruption.

But putting that aside, I would probably say something like capitalism is a source of American entrepreneurialism and growth, and that slowing down the rate of democracy, undermining the impartiality and rule of law, and undermining our administrative state, not funding science, stopping immigration of talented PhD students are going to be bad for American capitalism in the long run.

We know that democracy and capitalism flourish and do well when they go together. And I'm not sure that that would have an impact, But I would say that the rise in patrimonialism, transactionalism, and wheeling and dealing that we see around the world is one that's going to make the world inherently less safe. There will be far less inclusive growth and rising inequality is just going to lead to massive instability around the world, as we've already seen.

The second thing I would appeal to, like Drew, is legacy. I would actually say go focus on the arch and on the ballroom because liberal democracy is the single greatest achievement of this American project over the past 250 years. Liberal democracy is historically very hard won and rare. Most people have lived and died under something like empires.

Second of all, it's the result of massive decades, if not centuries, of popular mobilization of the kind we are now seeing in Iran.

And third, it has provided tremendous hope and inspiration to people around the world who want to live in freedom and try to secure it. That is what makes America great.

We have adapted and been flexible about what our democratic values are over time to expand to become a truly multiracial democracy. And he is messing it up a little bit.

And so I would say, sir, please go golf, go enjoy your life. And your legacy can be a positive one if you just stop attacking the thing that makes us the best country in the world.

Kahl: Play more golf and it makes America great again. Abbas, five minutes with the president on Iran.

Milani: I would say that you might think you can solve other problems instinctively with the instincts of a gambler. With Iran you can't. It is an old, complicated problem. Every administration has tried to solve this problem for the last forty-five years and it is not that simple. You can't bomb your way out of Iran's nuclear problem. You cannot bomb your way into a democracy in Iran. Iranian democracy has to be made by the people of Iran.

Don't threaten to destroy the civilization of Iran, which is one of the greatest civilizations in the world. If you destroy Iranian civilization, you are destroying part of the greatest legacy that we have, which is wisdom, which is prudence, which is philosophy. So these kinds of threats work against the people of Iran ridding themselves of this regime.

The only way we are going to have peace in the Middle East is if we understand how powerful that desire for democracy, the desire for amity with the United States is amongst the people of Iran. These kinds of politics, these kind of rhetorics, placing the decisions about this into hands that know nothing about this area, who are financially involved in this area. And they are dealing with people who know all too well how to use financial weaknesses of leaders to get what they want.

Look at what that kind of money has done to soccer.

That same thing is happening to American foreign policy. That is a dead end, Mr. President. Allow the processes that have made this country what this country is, work. Otherwise, that legacy is going to be that you'd fought a regime, you brought a lot of destruction, but you left a regime that is weaker domestically, but regionally has much more power

It controls two of the choke points of the world economy: Bob al-Mandab and the Strait of Hormuz. You went in there without thinking that they would close the Strait of Hormuz. Every indication was that they would do that if you attacked them. And particularly attack killing the top leadership. They were on record that they were going to close the Strait of Hormuz.

I would have told them, read what other administrations have done. Read what Colin Kahl probably told the president when somebody suggested to Biden that they should attack. I wouldn't be surprised if Colin was in the room and said, “Don't do it.”

I would say that you can truly leave a historic legacy if you can bring about the Abrahamic Accord. But to bring about the Abrahamic Accord, you need to convince the Israelis that Palestinians also have a right to a state. Without that, the Abrahamic Accord won't happen. With Abrahamic Accord, I think you will move the needle historically in the Middle East.

Kahl: I will just say: Abbas and I have talked about this a lot. We as Americans, we are a very powerful country and we are also problem solvers and we like to believe that we can solve world problems. We often cannot. It's also the case that some problems are not solvable in the near term. You have to muddle through and manage, which is super unsatisfying. The historical record is that pretty much everything that has happened was not only predictable, it was predicted, which is I think the most unfortunate aspect around a lot of this stuff.

Steve, two years ago, Trump said if he's elected he would solve the Ukraine war in twenty four hours. So we're twenty four months since the last election. If you had five minutes with the president on the Russia Ukraine conflict, what would your advice be?

Pifer: Well, I've written a lot over the last eighteen months about the Trump policy towards Russia-Ukraine. Polls show like eighty-five percent of Americans do not trust, do not like, do not respect Putin. Polls show that Americans support Ukraine. And I think if you actually took a poll in Congress, you would find most in Congress share those views. And I would tell the president, Mr. President, your policy in terms of buying diesel from Russia, not putting more pressure on Russia, and now turning it against Ukraine by cutting off some of the intelligence sharing: it’s wrong.

It's wrong morally. It's wrong strategically. And it's wrong in terms of your effort, your proclaimed desire to try to mediate it into this war. It's wrong morally because Russia is clearly the aggressor. It was Russia that seized Crimea with military force in 2014 and then went on to get involved in fighting in Donbas. It was Russia that launched the invasion in 2022. Ukraine is the victim.

It's wrong strategically, because if Russia prevails in this war, either they win on the battlefield, or perhaps they benefit from a bad peace deal. That's going to embolden Vladimir Putin. And that means a greater Russian threat to Europe and to vital American national security interests. I don't think Mr. Trump understands that at all.

But it's also wrong in terms of his effort to try to mediate a solution. But if you look over the past year, the Ukrainians have indicated readiness to make some pretty painful concessions to achieve peace, including perhaps accepting the de facto loss of a lot of territory. The Russian position has not budged.

Recently Russian officials have said there's been no change in the Russian position since 2024. And part of the problem is Mr. Trump's failure to use his leverage to push the Russians to negotiate. And this is why the decision to start buying diesel fuel from Russia is so bad. We're now basically sending American dollars that are going to feed part of that Russian military machine by releasing some of the financial pressure on Russia that might force them otherwise to adopt a different course.

And what I worry about that is: of course it's bad implications for Russia-Ukraine, but in other places where they look at this, not only in Moscow, but in Beijing, other capitals where they see us as the adversary, they're looking at this as not a sign of American strength. They're seeing it as a sign of American weakness and they're looking at saying, “Gee, look how well people like Putin can play Trump.” That's not good for our foreign policy.

Kahl: So twice this year already, President Trump has met with Xi Jinping. Once in China, once here in the United States, they're likely to meet again at some point this year. Despite all the competition and rhetoric, there does appear to be an effort between the two leaders to have a detente or a pause, a timeout on some of the rougher edges of the relationship. If you had five minutes with the president on China issues or Taiwan issues or China Taiwan issues, what would your recommendations be?

Mastro: This is one area where I think we oversimplify. We think that China's policies are because of Xi Jinping. And that if we had a different leader in China, everything would just be rosy again. But Xi Jinping is a product of the system. So for me, it's not the case that if Xi Jinping left, the next leader would be like, you know what? I think it's better for China to just do everything the United States demands of it and be number two in the world.

I would tell the president that U.S.-China competition is not about the United States or about China. But that power is actually bestowed upon either country by the rest of the world. Whether or not the United States is a great power, whether or not China is a great power, largely depends on how the rest of the world sees these two countries and sees the benefit, or the costs, of one of them having more power than the other.

Now, the United States as a global superpower, this is largely beneficial for many countries in the system. But first, we have to be honest that it's not the best system for everybody. To Didi's point, there's a lot of autocracies out there that would prefer that it wasn't the United States that is in charge.

But secondly, there's a whole part of the world—the majority of the world, the developing world—that the United States has ignored for decades and decades and decades. And that Trump has gone even a step farther by reducing what I would say the little amount of development aid, soft power that we had in this part of the world.

Now, I can tell you one thing for sure: this is a number one priority in China. Xi Jinping wants to be the leader of the developing world. So, are the Chinese wrong or are the Americans wrong to basically decide the value? But I can say in terms of a business sense, this is the area where you're gonna have the most returns.

Now, from my own biases, I am—not here on this stage—but still in the military. I've been in the military for seventeen years. I believe in the effectiveness of the use of force at international politics. Otherwise, I wouldn't dedicate so much of my life to serving uniform.

But that being said, diplomacy, soft power, developmental assistance, all these other things that the United States used to do more of . . . having a U.S. information service . . . these make a huge difference.

And so I would tell him to invest so much more in the other tools of power. China lists twelve types of tools of power, which military power is only one of them. And they're just as serious about the other ones.

And as much as the allies and partners periodically can be annoying about stuff, they are the source of U.S. power. In many respects, the U.S. military cannot project power without them. And so this isn't a favor that the rest of the world is doing for us that over a hundred countries allow U.S. access, bases, and overflight. This is something that the United States needs to maintain its position and to protect its interests abroad.

So don't only meet with Xi Jinping and shake hands and roll out the red carpet and say, “Okay, since I met with him and we have now a comfortably tense relationship, everything is going well.”

Take a look at the rest of the world and figure out how to maintain what has historically been U.S. dominance of the international system, a U.S. led liberal order. How do we go back to being sure that that is something that my kids are going to enjoy afterwards?

Kahl: I want to ask our last lightning questions. Everybody in this room is super committed to Stanford in all sorts of ways. What do you think Stanford could be doing more of, maybe could be doing better to help the world understand or address these issues? Abbas?

Milani: I think we are in one of the most remarkable moments in history. We are in the process of not just gradual incremental change or historic change. We're in the process of what can only be called epochal change. The changes we are about to witness and are witnessing are only, in my view, comparable to Renaissance, where everything about everything changed. We are in the process of experiencing that.

In that first phase of modernity, America, I think, is the most successful example of a democratic secular society. Going into this new phase, that model needs to be saved. American democracy needs to be saved. American democracy can only be saved if it has a more global view, a more inclusive view, and a more tolerant view. We need to begin this at Stanford. We need to teach the culture of tolerance in classes.

It is increasingly difficult to discuss difficult topics in class. I'm not talking about bioengineering. You can get away with anything in bioengineering. But try to have that level of discussion about the Arab Israeli problem, the Iranian problem, American democracy problem, race problem, gender problem. You get into serious difficulties. We need to defend that. Democracy requires defending.

I come from a place that went from an authoritarian regime to a pseudo-totalitarian regime. I came from Iran in 1986, a country that was literally at war with the United States. And twenty-two years, ago I became head of the Iranian studies program at Stanford. That would not be possible anywhere else in the world. I know the value of democracy, and I don't think at Stanford we're doing enough to defend this most valuable cherished gift that we have.

We need to cultivate, strengthen that culture.

Kahl: Didi.

Kuo: Every morning when you wake up and read the news, it can be a bummer. And I will say coming to work makes me feel better. And that's because FSI is a really special place where the approach to these topics is scholarly.

Therefore, we understand, you know, this is a kind of unique historical time, but it's one that we can really try to understand with an interdisciplinary lens and an understanding that our goal is to take academic knowledge and get it out into the world: use it to try to improve outcomes, provide policy recommendations, engage with the media or with thought leaders and people who can actually shape the public understanding of these issues.

And that is something I see creating a lot of purpose among my colleagues and creating special places outside of academic disciplines for those of us who care about engaging with the world to really unite academic knowledge with public understanding.

But the second thing is also focused on students. In California, we are super far from Washington, D.C. So if you go to Georgetown, for example, you have a lot of students who know what government is, they're going to get an internship. Over here, sometimes all the students know is Silicon Valley's over there. They're going to solve the world's problems through the private sector. I don't know, man. We have governments for a reason. AI, climate change, all of these issues are going to need to be tackled through regulation, not just through the moral binds or whatever that the president thinks that we can regulate AI with.

So I think that any way of encouraging public service and engagement with government—whether that's local, national, or international, going to other countries—is super important. And once students get a taste and a flavor of that public service, they get really into it. It's just that it's far for us, geographically, to engage. And I therefore think it's really important to encourage those kinds of opportunities.

Kahl: Amen. Steve?

Pifer: Yeah, well let me start with I some things I think that Stanford does and FSI do well. I think we do a good job on Russia-Ukraine of explaining to students what's going on, why it matters. And it's not just Stanford speakers, but we bring a lot of people in.

So on Wednesday, we had an American and a Ukrainian who are based in Kyiv. They came to talk for an hour and a half on Ukraine's innovative defense culture, where under the pressure of war they're just doing incredible changes in terms of how fast they react to things and get new weapons into the field.

There's a lot of . . . I won't list everybody, but a lot [of us] write, speak, do media on this to try to educate the broader public. We have a law school professor who organized a group of his students to track down and identify American law firms that are helping Russian oligarchs hide their wealth in the United States. And that was part of a broader effort that Stanford was running with the International Working Group on Sanctions, where we did about twenty-six papers advising on how sanctions on Russians could be tightened. So I think there's a lot of things that are being done that are good.

The more difficult challenge I think we have is how do we talk to the U.S. government? When people like Colin were in during the Biden administration, I think we had a lot of access. The administration didn't agree with everything we asked them to do, but there was a dialogue there.

I'm not sure anybody FSI has on the Russia Ukraine thing any kind of contact with people who matter in the Trump administration. So it's difficult to have the kind of conversation where you might suggest here are some ways to move forward. But I think that's going to be one of the real challenges is how can we affect government policy directly?

Kahl: And I think this is a really important point because I think this can be interpreted as basically saying, well, okay, when Democrats are in, people can have access. But it's not actually about partisan politics. It's about this particular administration's approach to outside expertise and which voices they tend to listen to. One can agree with it or disagree with it. It's it just is a thing, which is traditionally places like universities and think tanks and other sources of analysis outside of government are just not prioritized in this

Pifer: After I left the government in 2004, we had lots of access as outsiders to the Bush administration. They welcomed that dialogue. I don't think this administration does.

Kahl: Oriana.

Mastro: That's a perfect segue to what I wanted to say about policy impact about how do we talk to the U.S. government? It's not only the U.S. government. As someone who works on China, the amount of which professors and students are engaging with China is less and less over time because all of these things have become politically difficult.

And to me, Stanford is an environment in which you should be able to take those risks. This is a place where you can have dialogues with the Chinese. This is a place where policy, political officials should feel like they can come and talk and engage with these issues.

And so to try to have that kind of interconnectivity in May, I launched this policy lab on the Indo-Pacific. I call it “policy-guided.” What that means is instead of sort of doing all this research and then writing an op-ed and hoping someone reads it and then maybe it has some impact, I identify the decision makers that have influence on that research area early on in the process, and I engage with them throughout the whole process so that they have a stake in making sure that they're getting the information they need when they need it.

And part of that is educating students not only on the substance on Indo-Pacific, but also skill sets. So part of that is we just launched something called the Commander Series, where I bring combatant commanders—so these are four-star generals who are in charge of every region of the world—to campus every quarter. They give a big public talk, which again, given the political environment, given everything, did come with some convincing. We now have three lined up for this year. But it's possible. It's possible to continue to engage. And then in addition to the public talks, ask them to do private master classes with the students.

Like having that exposure to students to do kind of the real world work and to have that direct policy impact, is it harder? Yes. Is it still possible at a place like Stanford? Absolutely.

Kahl: I want to really foot stomp something because at the intersection of what Oriana and Steve just said: yes, there's a degree to which we're not as plugged into Washington as maybe in previous administrations. But the flip side of that is, actually, Stanford is a safer space for conversations among those parts of Washington that want to have conversations outside of Washington because we are further away.

We are seen as less ideological. We're not seen as particularly partisan. We're seen as a font of technical knowledge because Silicon Valley plays its own role in the current ecosystem for better or worse. So that's also an opportunity, not just a constraint.

Endy: I love this question. We heard that we're in a moment of epochal change not seen since the Renaissance. That's stunning. I'm going to carry that for a long time.

I wonder what Mr. and Mrs. Stanford think of us. If they appeared today and saw what we are now, how would they react? One of the things I go back and read is the purpose they wrote in the charter of the university. And there's a sentence, this really interesting sentence. It says: “to have an influence in behalf of humanity.”

And the first time I read it, I thought it was a typo. I thought it was supposed to be “on” behalf of humanity. But it says “in behalf of,” which really means out there doing stuff. And I think we could do a lot better in that regard.

I think we're pretty good at being Stanford. I think we could do a lot better in behalf of humanity. And FSI and CISAC is very much about that. But what does that look like? And and so I'll check some things out that may seem adjacent, but I think they're important. Number one.

I used to be chair of undergraduate admissions and financial aid for the university. We're not need-blind for international applicants. We are for domestic, but not for international. We could do it, but we always manage to not do it. This would be a good year to do it.

The second thing I think we need to do is we need to bring Stanford out into the United States. I used to teach a version of Introduction to Bioengineering to five hundred high school students in Title I high schools. And they were registered as Stanford students as high school students in low income high schools throughout the country.

I think we could have a service requirement for undergraduates where they're teaching fellows in high schools as upperclassmen helping with this. We could have five thousand extra students a year as high school students. So I think there's some macro moves the university could make that would amplify what FSI and other places are doing, and we need to get on with it.

Kahl: This is such a great place to end because the panel today was global threats and essentially what we can do about them. And I think what you heard, and frankly, where I think FSI is unique, not only at Stanford, but in the world in many respects, is that so many of the things that we read about or that we watch on YouTube are at the cross currents of these huge geopolitical changes, these world changing technological developments, and contentious domestic politics in the future of democracy here and around the world. Like these are the things that all of us care about.

Just as people as Americans, we are deeply invested at FSI. And I think what you've heard is like we can choose to engineer a world of abundance and opportunity, or we can create a lot of dangerous things that make life worse. We can choose to defend freedom in the United States and around the world, or we can choose not to. We can choose to wield American power with wisdom and with a degree of restraint, or unwisely with hubris, like an international wrecking ball. 

These are choices. These are not inevitabilities. These are choices. And I think at FSI, we believe we can help empower the right choices, especially by empowering our students. The thing that keeps me most optimistic when we have conversations like this — I think everybody up here would agree — is how awesome our students are, and how much more incredible they are at, you know, as twenty-year-olds than we were as twenty year olds.

And what I often say is smart and incredible as all these people on stage and all the other people you encounter, all the people in this room are, we're not going to solve the world's problems.

The best we can do is keep the problems solvable and empower our students to solve our problems. And the good news is our students are completely capable of doing that.

So thank you very much, and thanks again to our panelists.

[END EVENT RECORDING]

Kahl: You've been listening to World Class from the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies at Stanford University. If you like what you're hearing, please leave us a review and be sure to subscribe on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts to stay up to date on what's happening in the world, and why.

Read More

Fmr Congressman and Ambassador Jeff Flake sits on stage with Professor Kathryn Stoner.
News

Does the Path to Bipartisanship Run Through Foreign Policy?

During his visit to the Freeman Spogli Institute, former Senator and Ambassador to Türkiye Jeff Flake reflected on domestic political divisions and issues where parties can come together.
Does the Path to Bipartisanship Run Through Foreign Policy?
Amy Zegart on World Class, a podcast by the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies at Stanford University.
Commentary

How Frontier Technology Is Rewriting the Rules of Power, Intelligence, and National Security

Amy Zegart joins Colin Kahl on the World Class podcast to discuss what's familiar and what's novel in how nations and other actors are competing politically, militarily, economically, and technologically.
How Frontier Technology Is Rewriting the Rules of Power, Intelligence, and National Security
Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump in conversation on the tarmac of the Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson on August 15, 2025 in Anchorage, Alaska.
Commentary

Russia-Ukraine War: Trump’s Wrong-Headed Turn toward Moscow

Trump’s policy turn is wrong-headed, both morally and strategically. And, instead of bringing the war closer to an end, he undermines his mediation bid and makes peace harder to achieve.
Russia-Ukraine War: Trump’s Wrong-Headed Turn toward Moscow
Hero Image
All News button
1
Subtitle

At Stanford's 2026 Reunion Homecoming, a panel of scholars from the Freeman Spogli Institute discussed challenges to democracy, the potential and dangers of biotechnology, the Russia-Ukraine and U.S.-Iran conflicts, and the U.S.-China relationship.

Date Label
Display Hero Image Wide (1320px)
No
Authors
Khushmita Dhabhai
News Type
News
Date
Paragraphs

Marcela Ibáñez, a visiting postdoctoral fellow at CDDRL, presented her research on how Chinese development finance influenced citizens' support for democracy in Latin America. The research challenged the conventional expectation that economic engagement with authoritarian powers facilitates the diffusion of authoritarian norms and weakens democratic commitments. Instead, Ibáñez presented evidence suggesting that Chinese financing could produce the opposite effect: increased support for democracy among citizens in recipient regions. A central contribution of the presentation was its examination of three mechanisms that might explain this democratic backlash.

The first, revealed appropriation, suggested that foreign financing alerted citizens to additional resources available to their government. Where leaders depended on narrow winning coalitions, citizens might anticipate that these resources would disproportionately benefit political insiders, thereby strengthening their preference for democracy.

The second mechanism, revealed priorities, proposed that completed foreign-funded projects exposed deficiencies in domestic public goods provision. By demonstrating what governments could have delivered but had failed to provide, such projects could generate dissatisfaction with existing political institutions.

The third mechanism, legibility of the incumbent, emphasized the informational significance of a government's relationship with an authoritarian patron. Chinese-financed projects could make the incumbent's authoritarian associations more visible, prompting citizens to reassess their own political institutions rather than China itself.

The empirical strategy combined geocoded development aid data with 19 waves of Latinobarómetro surveys conducted between 2000 and 2021. Using a staggered treatment design and a two-way fixed-effects counterfactual estimator, the analysis examined changes in democratic attitudes following the arrival of Chinese-financed projects. The findings indicated that support for democracy increases at the time of Chinese financing commitments. Importantly, similar effects were not observed for projects financed by other donors, suggesting that the response is driven by the type of committed project.

The empirical findings provided stronger support for the first and third mechanisms. Democratic support increased following financing commitments rather than project completion, consistent with revealed appropriation. The stronger effects under electoral autocracies, alongside declining confidence in state institutions, were consistent with the legibility mechanism.

Overall, the presentation offered an important reconsideration of authoritarian influence abroad. Rather than treating foreign engagement primarily as a vehicle for institutional or ideological diffusion, it demonstrated how external financing could reshape citizens' evaluations of domestic governance. Its broader implication was that authoritarian economic influence did not necessarily produce authoritarian political preferences, although whether increased democratic support translated into greater democratic accountability remained an open question.

Read More

Benjamin Yoel presented his research in a CDDRL seminar on October 29, 2026.
News

How International Actors Can Shape Support for Opposition to Democratic Backsliding

Research by Benjamin Yoel, based on two survey experiments with more than 4,300 respondents, finds that backing an opposition movement raises public approval more than criticizing the government.
How International Actors Can Shape Support for Opposition to Democratic Backsliding
Milada Anna Vachudova presented her research in a Rethinking European Development and Security (REDS) seminar on October 22, 2026, co-sponsored by the Center on Democracy, Development and the Rule of Law (CDDRL) and The Europe Center (TEC).
News

Can Europe Turn Crisis Into Unity?

Milada Anna Vachudova traces how EU institutions mobilized rapidly after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and the harder task of converting solidarity into lasting capability.
Can Europe Turn Crisis Into Unity?
Chris Dann presented his research in a CDDRL seminar on October 15, 2026.
News

How Autocracies Buy Legitimacy With Concrete and Steel

Research by CDDRL pre-doctoral fellow Christopher Dann finds that 21st-century autocracies use large-scale infrastructure to win public confidence and sustain authoritarian rule.
How Autocracies Buy Legitimacy With Concrete and Steel
Hero Image
Marcela Ibáñez presented her research in a CDDRL seminar on November 5, 2026.
Marcela Ibáñez presented her research in a CDDRL seminar on November 5, 2026. | Nora Sulots
All News button
1
Subtitle

Marcela Ibáñez shows that Chinese-financed projects tend to raise, not lower, citizens’ support for democracy, especially under leaders who rely on small winning coalitions.

Date Label
In Brief
  • Visiting postdoctoral fellow Marcela Ibáñez presented research showing that Chinese development finance increased, rather than weakened, citizens’ support for democracy in Latin America.
  • Combining geocoded aid data with 19 waves of Latinobarómetro surveys from 2000 to 2021, the analysis found the strongest effects in regions led by officials who depend on small winning coalitions in electoral autocracies.
  • The findings offered stronger support for two of three proposed mechanisms, revealed appropriation and legibility of the incumbent, though whether greater democratic support leads to accountability remains unresolved.
Display Hero Image Wide (1320px)
Yes
All Publications button
1
Publication Type
Journal Articles
Publication Date
Subtitle

Preprimary education is central to the global education agenda, including Sustainable Development Goal 4.2. Despite global momentum in low- and middle-income countries, cross-national evidence on long-term outcomes associated with preprimary education legislation remains limited. Here we applied a matrix-completion approach with subgroup and sensitivity analyses using 495 nationally representative surveys from 1990 to 2024, covering nearly 6.7 million women across 117 countries. Eligibility under the legislation was associated with higher educational enrolment and completion, and with more gender-egalitarian attitudes, more favourable empowerment-related behaviours and greater reproductive autonomy. For example, eligibility was associated with higher female primary-school enrolment (1.21 percentage points (pp); 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.52 to 1.91; P < 0.001) and completion (0.75 pp; 95% CI 0.24 to 1.25; P = 0.004), greater disapproval of wife-beating (1.04 pp; 95% CI 0.53 to 1.56; P < 0.001), greater participation in decisions about husbands’ earnings (3.25 pp; 95% CI 2.50 to 4.00; P < 0.001) and greater ever use of contraception (2.96 pp; 95% CI 2.33 to 3.59; P < 0.001). Eligibility under the legislation was also associated with lower rates of adolescent childbearing (−2.41 pp; 95% CI −2.67 to −2.14; P < 0.001) and child marriage (−0.43 pp; 95% CI −0.71 to −0.15; P = 0.003). These findings provide cross-national evidence directly relevant to ongoing policy discussions surrounding Sustainable Development Goal 4.2 and broader global development agendas, while emphasizing the importance of implementation capacity and equitable system expansion.

Journal Publisher
Nature Human Behaviour
Authors
Scott Rozelle
All Publications button
1
Publication Type
Journal Articles
Publication Date
Subtitle

Objectives
We examined the effectiveness of a school-based intervention focusing on sugar-sweetened beverage (SSB) harms and nutrition-label understanding among children and adolescents.

Study design
We conducted a school-based, two-arm, cluster-randomised controlled trial among upper-primary and lower-secondary students in six Chinese schools. The trial was embedded within the 2022 wave of the Health and Nutrition Panel Survey (HNPS-2022). Classes were the unit of randomisation; within each school and target grade, classes were randomly assigned to a video (<5 min) on SSB harms and nutrition labels or eyesight protection. The trial included a real choice experiment (RCE) and a discrete choice experiment (DCE). Primary outcomes were the probability of selecting a full-sugar fermented milk drink (FMD) at actual beverage selection in the RCE, and the direction and relative importance of preferences for prespecified beverage attributes in the DCE. We used ANCOVA and mixed logit models.

Results
Between September and October 2022, 24 classes were randomly assigned to control (12 classes; 653 students) or intervention (12; 649); 1269 students were analysed (641 control and 628 intervention). At actual beverage selection, 367/641 (57.3%) control participants selected the full-sugar rather than the low-sugar FMD, compared with 228/628 (36.3%) intervention participants (adjusted absolute difference −0.21, 95% CI -0.28 to −0.15; p < 0.0001; adjusted odds ratio 0.39, 95% CI 0.30 to 0.51; p < 0.0001). In the DCE, beverage profile (a combination of beverage type and sugar content) had the highest relative importance (49.6%), followed by price (38.4%). The intervention shifted preferences towards healthier options, especially among primary school students.

Conclusions
A brief health literacy intervention supported healthier immediate beverage choices, but sustained SSB prevention will require clearer, child-friendly sugar information and school policies that make healthier beverage options easier to choose.

Journal Publisher
Social Science & Medicine
Authors
Scott Rozelle
-
2027 SCCEI China Conference banner image.

 

The Stanford Center on China's Economy and Institution's (SCCEI) annual China Conference brings together leading voices from policy, industry, and academia to examine key economic trends in China and their implications for the world.

This year's theme and selected speakers will be announced in the coming months. Updates will be posted here as confirmed.

*Schedule is subject to change  

Location: 
Bechtel Conference Center
Encina Hall
616 Jane Stanford Way, Stanford University

*Topics, speakers, and timing will be confirmed soon. 



10:00 AM - 10:25 AM  Registration & Light Breakfast

10:25 AM - 10:30 AM  Welcome & Opening Remarks


10:30 AM - 12:00 PM  Keynote Address


12:00 PM - 1:00 PM  Lunch
 
1:00 PM - 2:00 PM  Session 1 
 

2:00 PM - 2:20 PM  Break
 
2:20 PM - 3:20 PM  Session 2 

 

3:20 PM - 3:40 PM  Break

3:40 PM - 4:40 PM  Session 3

 

4:40 PM - 5:00 PM Closing Remarks & Networking



Questions? Contact scceichinaconference@stanford.edu 

 


Bechtel Conference Center
Encina Hall
616 Jane Stanford Way, Stanford University

This event is by invitation only.

Conferences
News Feed Image
banner_2_to_1_dimensions_2026-no_topic.png
Date Label
-
Christine Wong Beyond Land and Debt: Rebuilding the Fiscal Foundation to Revitalize Local Government Finance in China Tuesday, December 8, 2026 12:00 PM - 1:30 PM (Pacific)

China’s local governments have long been the engines of its economic miracle, and their ailing finances have been a drag on growth in the past few years.

Under China’s decentralized system, local governments drive 85% of public spending and over 80% of infrastructure investment.  A decade-long fiscal erosion, the recent collapse in land revenues, and soaring debt have left them struggling to meet spending needs. These challenges stem from deep structural issues—a tax structure that lags behind economic changes, an overreliance on land sales to fund infrastructure and debt repayment, and a misalignment between spending responsibilities and fiscal capacity.  

Bold reforms will be needed to close the fiscal gap, revise how revenues are shared, and realign revenues with spending. They are all the more urgent given China’s rapidly ageing population and the looming expenditure needs in health and pensions that will require significant adjustments in the composition of public spending. 

Christine Wong

Speaker: Christine Wong is Visiting Professor at the Schwarzman College at Tsinghua University.  She is also Honorary Professorial Fellow at the Asia Institute, University of Melbourne; and Non-Resident Senior Fellow at the East Asian Institute (EAI), National University Singapore.  She was Distinguished Visiting Fellow at the Australian Centre on China in the World, Australian National University in January – August 2026.

Christine has taught at top universities around the world. From March 2020 to January 2026, she was Visiting Research Professor at the EAI, National University of Singapore.  Before that, Christine was Founding Director of the Centre for Contemporary Chinese Studies and Professor of Chinese Studies at the University of Melbourne.  From 2007 to 2013, she was Professor of Chinese Public Finance and Director of Chinese Studies at the University of Oxford.  During 2000-2007 she held the Henry M. Jackson Professorship at the Henry M. Jackson School of International Studies, University of Washington.  She has also taught economics at the University of California, Santa Cruz and Berkeley campuses; and at Mount Holyoke College in Massachusetts.

In addition, Professor Wong has held senior staff positions in the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank, and worked with other international agencies including the IMF, OECD, and UNDP.

Professor Wong’s research has largely focused on China’s public finances. She has published widely on the impact of fiscal decentralization on macroeconomic management and policy implementation in education, health, social welfare, environmental protection, and urbanization in China.

 

Directions and Parking > 

Philippines Conference Room (C330)
Encina Hall, 3rd Floor
616 Jane Stanford Way, Stanford, CA 94305

Seminars
Date Label
Authors
News Type
News
Date
Paragraphs

What makes an innovation cluster successful? Some regions rely on research universities and venture capital, while others draw power from established industries, manufacturing networks, and government coordination. Knowing these differences is essential for universities and companies seeking international research partnerships.

At a recent seminar hosted by the Stanford Next Asia Policy Lab (SNAPL) at Stanford Asia-Pacific Research Center, three experts from the Swedish Foundation for International Cooperation in Research and Higher Education (STINT) – Executive Director  Andreas Göthenberg, Science Fellow in Japan and South Korea Laura Barbieri, and Representative in China and APAC Erik Forsberg – discussed two leading innovation regions: Tokyo-Yokohama and China’s Greater Bay Area. Drawing on new reports and interviews with regional stakeholders, they shared findings on how each ecosystem developed, where its strengths lie, and how international partners can engage successfully.

Their core insight is that no universal formula exists for scaling innovation. Recognizing how each ecosystem works is the first step toward aligning engagement strategies for successful, high-impact collaboration.


Sign up for APARC newsletters to receive insights and analysis from our scholars and guest speakers > 



Look Beyond Rankings to Understand Regional Strengths


Tokyo-Yokohama has built its position through more than a century of industrial and scientific expertise. Its innovation ecosystem connects major corporate research laboratories, universities, and national research institutes, supported by substantial corporate and public investment.

For years, this region topped the World Intellectual Property Organization’s (WIPO) global innovation cluster rankings. Its move to second place in 2025, due to the introduction of venture capital activity as an indicator, reflected differences in funding methods rather than indicating a decline in research quality.

China’s Greater Bay Area presents a contrasting model. This megacity region systematically combines nine key cities in Guangdong Province along with the Special Administrative Regions of Hong Kong and Macao. Its innovation system developed alongside manufacturing, with companies and industrial supply chains driving technological development before large-scale university research emerged as a defining feature. Shenzhen illustrates this advantage: the city’s electronics markets and supplier networks enable entrepreneurs to easily source components and quickly develop prototypes.

Instead of relying on ranked lists, universities and companies should assess regions according to the specific capabilities they need. While Tokyo-Yokohama offers deep institutional research capacity, China’s Greater Bay Area combines industrial scale with rapid product development.

Connect Research to Industries That Can Scale It


In Tokyo-Yokohama, established institutions and corporate research and development play crucial roles in driving innovation. The environment sustains continuity and long-term growth, but complex governance and limited venture capital can slow commercialization, particularly in deep technology and life sciences.

On the other hand, the Greater Bay Area uses a combination of research and manufacturing. Shenzhen and Guangzhou have robust industrial capacity and an expanding research infrastructure, while Hong Kong brings internationally connected universities and research networks. This evolving network of university campuses and research centers is fostering additional links between these resources.

However, it is important to note that the Greater Bay Area is not a single, uniform ecosystem. Hong Kong, Macao, and mainland Guangdong operate under different legal, educational, funding, and administrative systems. These differences create practical barriers to moving people, money, data, and technology across borders.

The key is to design partnerships around a pathway from research to real-world application. In Japan, this could mean building stronger industry-university connections and developing industrial doctoral programs. In the Greater Bay Area, it means identifying the right jurisdiction and considering cross-border constraints from the start.

Build Relationships Before Expecting Results


Barbieri emphasized that international collaboration in Tokyo-Yokohama is concentrated among leading institutions. Approximately 55% of scientific publications from the cluster involve international co-authors, while around 7% of patent filings include foreign partners or inventors. This suggests that, while international research collaboration is more established, cross-border commercial partnerships are still developing.

Platforms such as Tokyo Innovation Base and SusHi Tech Tokyo can help international partners make those crucial initial connections. Still, sustained collaboration generally requires relationships with universities, research institutes, and individual research groups. Tying projects to Japan’s mission-oriented strategies, including Society 5.0 and Green Innovation, can also assist in finding common goals and potential financial support.

Institutional agreements matter, but they are not enough. Memoranda of understanding can provide legitimacy and facilitate cooperation; trusted relationships between researchers are what make joint projects work.

It is important to combine institutional assistance with researcher-level engagement. International partners should identify specific collaborators, set shared research objectives, and dedicate time to build trust rather than pursuing broad, surface-level engagement.

Treat Internationalization as a Long-Term Strategy


Both regions face challenges with talent mobility, governance, and geopolitics. Japan aims to balance openness with protecting key technologies, all while managing language barriers and a shortage of specialized researchers.

In China, growing research capabilities coexist with elevated security concerns and restrictions that limit some researchers’ international travel. Comprehending this policy landscape is key to successfully navigating collaborations.

Göthenberg’s broader argument was that international engagement must be guided by science intelligence. It requires a systematic, evidence-based analysis to help institutions grasp global research trends, pinpoint opportunities, and anticipate risks.

For universities and companies, this calls for moving beyond instinct or familiar networks when choosing international partners. It requires knowing where expertise lies, how funding and governance operate, and whether a partnership can deliver sustained mutual benefit.

Tokyo-Yokohama and China’s Greater Bay Area demonstrate two distinct routes to innovation at scale. The most effective international strategies recognize these differences, connect complementary strengths, and prioritize focused and durable partnerships instead of seeking broad connections alone.



View STINT's recent reports on global science and innovation clusters, part of its Outlook library: 

Read More

Two people walking in Memorial Court, Main Quad, Stanford Campus. Text: "Shorenstein APARC Call for Applications: 2027-2029 Fellowships."
News

Stanford’s Asia-Pacific Research Center Invites Applications for 2027-2029 Postdoctoral and Visiting Fellowships

The center and its research programs offer multiple postdoctoral and visiting fellowships in Asian studies starting in fall quarter 2027. Opportunities are open to scholars of contemporary Asia from a wide range of disciplines, encompassing both pan-regional research and specialized tracks focused on specific regions and themes.
Stanford’s Asia-Pacific Research Center Invites Applications for 2027-2029 Postdoctoral and Visiting Fellowships
Urban architecture of Suzhou Industrial Park. China.
News

How China’s Debt-Ridden Local Governments Are Rewriting Their Economic Development Playbook

Having lost their primary source of revenue from land finance, indebted Chinese counties and cities are pursuing new strategies to sustain development, pivoting toward industrial parks and venture capital, Stanford political scientist Jean Oi observes in her recent fieldwork.
How China’s Debt-Ridden Local Governments Are Rewriting Their Economic Development Playbook
Illustration of three speech bubbles representing (from left to right) the flags of the EU, Japan, and South Korea.
Commentary

EU-Japan-South Korea Cooperation Is Indispensable Now

The trilateral is more feasible – and more important – than ever before.
EU-Japan-South Korea Cooperation Is Indispensable Now
Hero Image
Shenzhen Talent Park cityscape, Guangdong, China.
Shenzhen Talent Park cityscape, Guangdong Province, China. The city's electronics markets and supplier networks drive technological development, a defining feature of China's Greater Bay Area innovation system. | Yinwei Liu via Getty Images
All News button
1
Subtitle

How do regions turn research and industrial capabilities into global innovation? A Stanford Next Asia Policy Lab seminar examined two distinct models in Tokyo-Yokohama and China’s Greater Bay Area.

Date Label
Display Hero Image Wide (1320px)
Yes
All Publications button
1
Publication Type
Journal Articles
Publication Date
Subtitle

Background
The Thinking Healthy Extended Program (THEP) is a nonspecialist-delivered mental health intervention targeting female caregivers (mothers and grandmothers) of children aged 6-36 months in rural China. It consists of 24 fortnightly group sessions, supplemented by individual home visits for caregivers who miss group sessions, and integrates cognitive reframing techniques, behavioral engagement, childrearing skills, and peer support. Embedded within a large-scale randomized controlled trial, this study aims to evaluate implementation fidelity of THEP, examine hypothesized mechanisms of change, and identify contextual factors, including enablers and barriers, that influenced intervention implementation.
 

Methods
In-depth interviews were conducted at 3 months and 10 months into the intervention implementation with 50 caregivers and 10 facilitators. The interview guides were developed based on the UK Medical Research Council’s process evaluation framework, with the facilitator interview guide focused on implementation fidelity, the caregiver interview guide focused on mechanisms of change, and contextual factors explored in both guides. All interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using thematic analysis.
 

Results
THEP facilitators demonstrated competence in coordinating schedules, delivering sessions, and engaging caregivers. Caregivers reported improvements in peer support and childrearing skills, along with some uptake of behavioral engagement. However, both facilitators and caregivers demonstrated limited understanding of cognitive reframing techniques. Grandmothers (who accounted for 43% of the sample in the current study) experienced greater challenges than mothers with respect to applying the four program mechanisms of change. Several contextual factors, including a child-focused orientation, distractions related to the presence of children at sessions, and intergenerational differences between mother and grandmothers, influenced THEP implementation.
 

Conclusions
THEP was feasible to deliver through nonspecialist facilitators, but implementation quality was constrained by limited understanding of cognitive reframing strategies and variation in caregiver engagement. Future adaptation and scale-up should prioritize facilitator capacity and intervention approaches that are more feasible for nonspecialist providers and more accessible to diverse caregivers.

Journal Publisher
SSM - Mental Health
Authors
Yuyin Xiao
Scott Rozelle
Lia Fernald
Subscribe to China